A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away, George Lucas created a nearly perfect Star Wars trilogy. I also hear there’s a prequel trilogy. Actually, I confess that though the prequel trilogy has Anakin flaws, and though it’s not as good as the original trilogy, I still really like the prequels. I remember the hype for every single prequel movie. Calling those movies garbage is revisionist history fueled by peer pressure. But it’s been a long time since we’ve had any Star Wars movie. Enter J.J. Abrams directing Star Wars: The Force Awakens. Now with more Disney! I still can’t get the screaming roar of the tie fighters out of my head.
A New Hope
Let’s get this out of the way: I really like The Force Awakens. I’m going to see it again. I’m eventually going to see it many times. I want to see it again right away so that I can absorb more of it, and also watch it without a critical eye. It’s a lot of fun. It’s a movie that anyone with any interest in Star Wars should see. Keep that in mind as I dissect it with a little more critical perspective. I’ll first touch on the negatives. And I’ll try to keep this spoiler free.
Let me put my taped nerd glasses on. That’s better. If you don’t want to hear the criticisms of someone who clearly cares too much about these movies, just skip to the section where I discuss the positive aspects of the movie.
The Dark Side
Though The Force Awakens is a really good movie, it’s not the original trilogy. I’m not sure whether it’s even fair to compare it to the original trilogy. But as a stand-alone movie, there are ways it could be a better movie. I blame it on the writing and the directing.
The biggest weakness is its pacing. Before the movie was released, one of my fears was that it would be too J.J. Abramsy. That fear was partially allayed, but not completely. He did mostly avoid making the Star Wars aesthetic too sterile and shiny, in the vein of his Star Trek movies. But just as the 2nd half of Star Trek: Into Darkness was one giant action sequence, this time the frantic pace of the action lasted virtually the entire movie. From the moment you start watching, you’re dropped right into an action scene, and it doesn’t relent. That’s why I can’t get the sound of those tie fighters out of my head; I don’t think there’s a place in the galaxy that doesn’t have them appear and start destroying things.
The constant action doesn’t give the story room to breathe. It’s a substitute for better dialog and a deeper story. The original trilogy was very deliberate about its pace, with action scenes spliced in at the right times. Indeed, during the few moments when The Force Awakens does slow down a bit, it’s a better movie because of it. It’s not a problem that’s specific to this movie’s relation to the original trilogy. It’s true of most movies. As an example, look at The Lord of the Rings trilogy versus The Hobbit trilogy. Greater drama and more immersive world building makes for a better movie than stringing together a bunch of action sequences while skimping on some of the deeper elements.
Again, a The Force Awakens is still very, very good. It’s just doesn’t reach the next level that it could reach. Particularly in light of some weaknesses with the villains.
In The Force Awakens, the First Order has essentially replaced the Empire. It’s not a spoiler to say that the two main villains are Kylo Ren and Supreme Leader Snoke. The problem with Snoke is that he’s entirely cgi. For as much as Abrams made an effort to use practical effects, an entire character made of cgi is disappointing (and there are plenty of other opportunities to notice more cgi, by the way).
As for Kylo Ren, he is ultimately weak, though he is truly a mixed bag. On the one hand, in every scene with his helmet on and the modulated deep voice, he’s a very compelling villain. He’s evil, he’s intimidating, and Adam Driver nails the acting. Without his helmet on, he’s a scared boy. That’s not Driver’s fault; the dichotomy is clearly how the character was written. But by the end of the movie, aside from one scene in which he commits an act that is both unforgivably evil and cowardly, there was too much of the scared boy. The screen presence of a Vader-like figure had completely disappeared. And I still think without his hood on, Kylo Ren’s helmet makes him look like he has the haircut of a toddler girl (no offense to toddler girls – especially mine, who’s a huge Star Wars fan).
The Force Awakens is also at times easily predictable. And for as much alien variety as it has, there can and should have been much more of a variety of weapons used by the First Order. As good as The Force Awakens was, it could have used even more creativity. And I will say flatly that there was not nearly enough Luke Skywalker. And that’s all I will say (albeit curtly) about that.
The Light
For as much as I criticize the weaknesses of The Force Awakens, there’s a lot to like. I mean, this movie brings characters from the original trilogy back into our lives. It’s what everybody has craved since the prequel trilogy left our beloved heroes behind.
The acting is incredible. John Boyega (Finn), Daisy Ridley (Rey), Oscar Isaac (Poe Dameron) and Adam Driver (Kylo Ren), performed perfectly. I love Finn and Rey, and their banter is highly entertaining. They are fantastic heroes for modern Star Wars movies, and I can’t wait to see more of them.
Harrison Ford (Han Solo) owned this movie. Every actor was great. But Ford’s screen presence was particularly charismatic. Of course, look at the guy’s resume. This is still the guy who played Han Solo in the original trilogy, Indiana Jones, and Rick Deckard in Blade Runner. And he brought it again for The Force Awakens.
J.J. Abrams clearly used the original trilogy as a starting point to inspire his vision for The Force Awakens. In one way, it plays like a greatest hits movie, with iconic scenes from the original trilogy inspiring similar settings for this movie. There’s a forest planet, a desert planet, a wintery planet, and myriad other nods to the original trilogy. As with the Mos Eisley Cantina, Maz Kanata’s fortified watering hole was a particular favorite of mine.
And those action scenes? For as much as I complained that there wasn’t enough drama between the action scenes, the action scenes themselves were pretty great.
My favorites, though, are the droids. R2D2 and C-3PO already have a special place in my heart, and they appear again to my great delight. I am beyond excited to add BB-8 to the robot family. And BB-8’s inclusion as a main character in the story was something that mimicked the original trilogy and it’s something that J.J. Abrams did very, very right.
The Verdict
Yes, despite my overly zealous critiquing, Star Wars: The Force Awakens is brining many people great joy. It’s not the original trilogy, and there are distinct ways that it could be improved even when you eliminate the original trilogy from the equation. But just as a music producer can take a classic masterpiece, sample it, and splice it with new music to make a modern hit (think RZA/Wu-Tang Clan), J.J. Abrams sampled the original trilogy, added his own flavor, and now there’s a modern hit movie. You have the original. You have the new thing. You can debate the merits of each and give credit to the old school. Ultimately, they’re both something to enjoy, and they’re each a product of their time. If you were ask me to envision a movie based on the original trilogy, but updated for 2015, it would look a lot like The Force Awakens.
Now get out there and go see it, so that nobody has to worry about spoiling anything for you.